• Isa@feddit.org
    111·
    18 hours ago

    The three weren’t given to the elves. They forged them by themselves and Sauron never laid hand on any of them.

    • HeavenlySpoon@ttrpg.network
      3·
      5 hours ago

      Well, they were given to Gil-Galad, Cirdon, and Galadriel (all elves)… by another elf, yes, but still.

      And they were still bound to the power of the One. Annatar still deceived Celebrimbor, even if he wasn’t there when the Three were made.

      So technically the quote is still correct.

      • Isa@feddit.org
        2·
        4 hours ago

        All true! But turning back to the meme Nanni (other than Celembrimbor) wasn’t deceived by the trick of Ea-nasir (other than the elves with Sauron). 😛 So that comparison wouldn’t … ~Okay, okay, I’ll shut up, al right! ;)~

    • Bubs@lemm.ee
      14·
      15 hours ago

      Did you just “Well akshually” the original movie line? On an edited meme about someone complaining about ancient copper? Lol.

      Look guys! We got a silmarillion nerd here!

      (I’m assuming that’s a silmarillion fact you’re arguing, otherwise I’ll look like a Muppet lol)

      • Isa@feddit.org
        8·
        7 hours ago

        Did you just “Well akshually” the original movie line?

        The akshually book line, but yeah, I’m afraid, I did so, yes.

        On an edited meme about someone complaining about ancient copper? Lol.

        Guilty as charged, I’m afraid.

        Look guys! We got a silmarillion nerd here!

        I’m very sorry, but …

        (I’m assuming that’s a silmarillion fact you’re arguing, otherwise I’ll look like a Muppet lol)

        That’s mentioned by Elrond in the Lord of the Rings during the council before they left Rivendell (I’ve not read the Silmarillion yet … sorry).