- cross-posted to:
- memes@lemmy.ml
- cross-posted to:
- memes@lemmy.ml
cross-posted from: https://lemmy.ml/post/55455975
what kind of communism? The philosophical one that has never been successfully implemented as a governmental basis? Or the totalitarian kind like russia and china? Because fuck that.
The report just asks about communism, it doesn’t specify, so it’s unknown what each responder actually thinks communism is. That being said, it’s not that communism has never successfully been implemented, it’s that humanity has never reached the communist stage in development. Both the USSR and PRC were/are socialist, which is a transitional status towards the global, fully collectivized, highly developed and advanced system of communism. They’re also democratic, though their democratic systems are utterly alien to most of us who lived and grew up in capitalist systems.
Both the former USSR and the present PRC have a system of councils, from the local to the highest levels. Local councils elect delegates from among them to form higher councils, who in-turn elect delegates to higher councils. Each rung democratically selects among itself who can best represent them. In the west, we are used to ritualistically electing the head of state every few years, whereas in socialist countries democracy plays more of an active role in people’s day to day life.
In the Soviet Union, factories were run by a trio, called the “Triangle.” There was the manager of the factory, who typically worked their way up from the bottom. There was the party representative, who was there to bring a more all-sided viewpoint that local viewpoints may miss. Finally, there was the trade union representative, who was elected by the rest of the workers at the factory. The trade unions set wage agreements, controlled the wall-newspaper (a form of newsletter for the factory), and were in charge of making sure the needs and interests of the rank and file were met. Unpopular managers were thrown out by the trade unions.
It’s easy to imagine a vignette and believe it to be reality, but when you actually look at historical reality it paints an extremely different picture from what our guts tell us. Our gut feelings have been shaped by the Red Scare, whether we realize it or not.
it’s not that communism has never successfully been implemented, it’s that humanity has never reached the communist stage in development.
Ah.
Yep. Communism is a global system, built on incredibly advanced productive forces. The various countries controlled by communist parties have always (correctly) considered themselves to be in the socialist stage. Here’s a diagram from Cheng Enfu of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences, for example:

Socialism has been established successfully, it’s just an enormous amount of work and development to get to communism, and socialist revolution has primarily come to semi-feudal, barely industrialized countries to begin with.
I don’t think there is a specific path. I started out as a young Christian goody two shoes patriot until like late elementary school. Shifted to anarchy and agnostic. Jumped to communism and atheism. Now I’m more socialism and some philosophical/undefined religious beliefs.
But I learned a lot about communism in college and it wasn’t jiving. Too much “this sounds good on paper” gone to shit to trust it. Forms of socialism have been successfully executed and in places where the citizens have a higher overall satisfaction.
For me, I went from liberal -> Socdem -> anarchist -> Marxist-Leninist, and only got firmer in my beliefs as a Marxist the more I studied existing and formerly existing socialist projects, as well as Marxist theory. There’s no one set path, of course, but I like to think that because Marxism is an endlessly evolving and flexible toolset based on dialectical materialism, more and more will come to it in time.
Fun fact: this is only true for the boomer generation. Newer studies have disproven this for both newer generations and also the pre-boomer generations globally.
People do sometimes change as they get older, but the net change for a population is basically 1:1 transfer between sides. Only one singular generation has ever proveably trended towards conservatism as they age.
Would love to see some newer data on this, because the general consensus just two years ago was that millenials were bucking the trend:

- Born into post-war boom with new deal policies really ramping up
- Reaps the benefits of new deal and a massive boom in unionization when they reach working age
- Gets a house, family, cars, vacations on a single union income
- Union provides all retirement funds via pensions and other post-retirement guarantees
- Starts investing spare money, since they don’t need to skimp and save for rent, food, utilities
- Unions and social services don’t make stock go brr as much as rampant capitalism
- Votes against unions and market regulations
- Stocks go brrr
- Retires
- Continues to vote for stocks go brr
- Unions collapse
- Social supports collapse
- Don’t care, stock go brr
- “Downsizes” by selling the house they bought for $15k for $2M into a low-income condo since they’re on pension now
- “It worked for us, you just need to pull up your bootstraps and get a starter home!” - the starter home being the one they just sold for $2M
- Confused why all the younger people are mad at them
Fun fact, Boomers are the only discreet generation.
1946-1964. You can see the Boomer generation on any global population chart. You cannot say the same for any other generation because the data isn’t there for any other generation. Before the Boomers and afterwards people just have kids when they have kids, but for the boomers, it was a massive population boom.
Society reshaped itself around the boomers because it had to. And they have shaped society ever since.
No other cohort of births has shaped the world in the same way.
Yeah it is pretty fascinating in the context of human history. Generations weren’t a concept, a group of people were so psychologically similar even across cultures they came up with the need for such a designation, then no other successive group has been similar enough and we’re back to the 10000+year norm of human existence.
Heh. 30% of Gen Z need to actually go live in a communist country before they make up their minds. Idiots.
Most people living in countries run by communist governments love it. I’d personally love to live in China.
I’ve gotten more conservative under the trump administrations, but only in the sense that any time he does anything, I think “don’t fucking touch that you piece of shit, leave it how it is”
“Leave it how it is” has never really been what conservatism meant, except to the extent that when it was invented, “how it is” happened to be monarchy. Make no mistake: when the status-quo isn’t authoritarian, “conservatives” entire goal is to change it to become so as swiftly and radically as possible.
The only way I’ve moved “right” is in believing there are certain crimes, like social murder, that I believe we should reserve the death penalty for.
Just join us filthy commies ☭ 👻
Definitely not more conservative. What is true is that I’ve become much less liberal. You know, since liberals are basically conservative next to my beliefs.
Not according the link. They think Marxism/socialism is what the Scandinavians are doing, and they like what the Scandinavians are doing. Which is, of course, regulated capitalism with a strong safety net.
It’s interesting that you don’t link directly to the study (it’s in the link provided). But then that would be to one of the most anti communist groups I have ever encountered. Their headline/tagline:
Communism Killed Over 100 Million We’re telling their stories.
Also the study is from 2020…
The older you get the worse at propaganda you get?
I linked it because it’s a funny source on an existing study. Many simply think socialism is what the Nordics are doing, correct, but many genuinely realize what socialism and communism are and are increasingly sympathetic.
Don’t you mean “us when we’re older?”
I can’t speak for everyone, but the more the merrier!
Almost 40 and that meme is too right wing for me
How so?
You want a communist state? you believe in states?
I want a socialist state as a transition to communism. Socialism in the immediate, communism in the long run.
Agree with you mate,
Gotcha! Just was a bit confused on why you considered the meme more “right-wing,” but it sounds like we are on a similar page.
Funny how we are so left that the signs used to represent us are too “right wing” for us.
Unlike when we are called libs by americans, which is only offensive for reasons americans can’t fathom
I don’t really consider the hammer and sickle to be more “right-wing.” It’s the symbol of Marxism-Leninism, of the unity of the working classes, the proletariat and peasantry. I’m a Marxist-Leninist, so the hammer and sickle represents me as well. Once you move onto anti-capitalism, I don’t think it makes much sense to compare in terms of left and right relationally, because it implies that that’s even a spectrum. There’s more and less idealist and materialist, more and less utopian and scientific, but left and right as comparisons lose meaning.
Gen-Z is still rather young. (I know the oldest are 30). Let’s check back in 10 years when they’re entering middle age. When retirement is around the corner and their life priorities are changing.
How are Millennials faring?
Not quite as radical, but still more radical than their predecessors. Each successive generation is more left, individuals do not get more conservative as they age.





