I have ADHD, and a fucking plan…
I’m not talking to a genie without a lawyer present
You can’t outwit a genie. That’s like…a main point.
You can, regardless of the point. If you make a water tight wish and they still screw with it, they’re not upholding their end of the deal. And since they’re slaves, essentially, you can make consequences happen.
what if you make your first wish “i wish that you [the genie] will interpret my wishes in the same way that i would choose to interpret them”
(the caveat here being that I’m stupid, so i probably still get monkey pawed)
The genie uses this wish to change how you would choose to interpret things to match their own. Which is still useful, because now you have an innate sense of how the genie will end up doing it.
I’d probably go with, “I wish to gain an understanding of how you would interpret future wishes I make, prior to having committed to them, and without any changes to the nature of my being like changing me into a genie.”
Still probably plenty fallible.
so ow I’m even more of a pedantic asshole? oof
I added a couple paragraphs before I saw your response. For posterity, the commenter above me only saw my first paragraph at the time of posting “so ow I’m even more of a pedantic asshole? oof”.
your additional paragraph seems closer to the desired solution (also ty for posterity mention)
The phoneme wish is just bad though. Just because you can now pronunce phonemes doesn’t mean you can do the same for allophones, therefore they wouldn’t be able to perfectly pronounce any language.
Yeah just say you can pronounce any and all phones without altering the physiology of your mouth and congrats you can pronounce every sound in every language perfectly, and on top of it every kind of lisp and speech impediment sound without any downsides. A bonus thing you would gain is probably perfect and very good pitch range, a glottis that you can control every part of extremely well and some other insanely good articulatory abilities. But at that point why not just ask to be able to speak any language that was ever written, spoken or used in any other manner and any that will be in the future?
That last one. I didn’t know I wanted that wish until I saw it in writing. I fucking hate buying gifts because I’m half bad at it. I know what it looks like to give a good gift, but when I miss the mark, it sucks.
I just stopped giving obligated holiday gifts and declined receiving in the future a long time ago and the vast majority of people are perfectly fine with that. I still buy stuff for other people, like buying meals or giving them something I made or even something they want but can’t afford, just not tied to an obligated event and those go over really well.
Its just the obligated ones based on events that suck.
I started asking.
Me: what you you want for Christmas? Them: not sure, what do you want? Me: socks Them: oh me too
Christmas comes, we trade socks. Easy.
BTW yes you want socks for Christmas. Socks are the perfect gift to ask for as long as you don’t have sensory requirements. The thing about being an adult is that in general, anything within a gift budget that I actually want I have already bought. But I can always use more socks. Money you spend on socks is money I don’t have to spend on socks, and can spend on hobbies instead, because I don’t have to spend my money on socks. Socks are consumables, they will eventually wear out and so any socks you buy will get used. T-shirts are a good one too.
Socks and T-shirts also leave a lot of room for people to find some really cool patterns or prints.
I don’t want people to buy me socks or any clothing due to a social obligation because I don’t end up wearing them and then it feels like I’m supposed to feel ungrateful. A lot of clothing just isn’t comfortable for me, especially tight fitting things like socks.
Buying my own socks means not having a random sock generator, and I spend the same amount of money for what I actually want.
I don’t really have sensory issues with socks, but I want all my socks to be exactly the same. So I don’t have to worry about pairing. The last thing I want is someone gifting me socks that don’t match.
That said, I did get 5 pairs of matching Darn Tough socks last Christmas, and that was a great gift.
A drawer full of socks that all match is the best! No need to pair them up after washing and you can get dressed in low light without worrying about mismatched colors.
Ah you’d fit into the sensory requirements I mentioned.
and I spend the same amount of money for what I actually want.
This is the same logic for why I want socks. I’m not picky about socks. Perhaps there is something that you aren’t picky about. Another good option are anything you consume. Chocolates, a bottle of wine, that sort of thing. That way you just eat it and it’s gone. They also tend to come in a wide price range so people can spend what they feel is appropriate.
What I don’t want is someone buying me an omelette maker or coffee tools or even kitchen utensils. I am picky and want to pick things out myself. Coffee beans are ok, once I drink them then they are gone.
You keep trying to sell me on gift giving and I reject the base premise that it is necessary or a good thing to do.
Oh sorry I wasn’t trying to. Mutual agreement not to give gifts is valid, and is the case with me for most people I know!
It’s not “a myriad of”. There’s not “one myriad” you can count. It’s just “split into myriad smaller fees”.
At least that’s how I understand it.
It’s plural “myriads” that is forbidden fyi.
Both are fine
I like to use myriad myriad
Well look at that. So ten thousand I guess, used in this way.
Y’all don’t get how genies work:
-
Okay, you get a thousand dollars a day. It can’t be traced to anything illegal, but law enforcement will hound you about it every day until you die. Also you go to jail for not reporting it on your taxes. And it’s all in pennies anyway.
-
You can learn to pronounce every language correctly, but you have no idea what it means. Congratulations, that also includes English, you’re now no longer able to communicate.
-
You constantly come up with great gift ideas for people you don’t even know. You become obsessed with getting these people their perfect gifts, but you don’t know their names or where they live. Their faces haunt your dreams and every time you close your eyes. This eventually drives you stark raving mad.
- It’s deposited into a bank so being in pennies means nothing. And it’s being reported, that’s why the money needs to be clean.
- Why would granting the ability to learn how to pronounce any sound remove the ability to understand those sounds? It’s not like granting money removes the ability to spend it in the first wish.
- Yeah, this one might be asking for what you’re saying. They “always” want to have the best gift ideas for “people” leaves the door open for the genie to make the power impossible to turn off or ignore. They specify the gifts are for every holiday and birthday. So while it’s still a mind boggling amount, they don’t need to make an infinite number of gifts. Although, the “with enough time to actually get it for them” bit does introduce some extra time magic to make that possible. Now that I think about it, this person wished to be Santa Clause.
Isn’t that just the monkey’s paw? I thought djinn (genies?) were all over the place, good bad neutral twink whatever
I think it’s the other way around.
Djinn are usually malevolent because they’ve been trapped in a lamp.
Monkey’s Paw I think is more like a machine going for the most efficient solution to a problem.
What’s the simplest way to make these people rich? Trip their son at work so they collect life insurance!
What’s the simplest way to resurrect their son? Just kinda, make the corpse get up.
What’s the simplest way to give their son peace? Ctrl-Z the last wish.
Notice how the last wish was worded vaguely but still worked as intended? That’s because the path of least resistance lined up with the intention. A genie could’ve made their zombie son be put into an immortal coma, giving their son “peace”.
You may have a point with the monkey’s paw. It’s usually described as a force of nature more than anything else, so it just Occam’s Razoring solutions to wishes would make some kinda sense.
Djinn or jinn are supernatural beings in Arabic mythology and aren’t innately good or evil. They are just like humans and it was believed they would be judged for their actions in front of Allah just like regular humans. There is no mention of them being able to grant wishes in the original mythology where they were shapeshifters and were blamed as the cause for mental disease and madness.
The wish granting genies are somewhat loosely related with the djinn of Arabic mythology. The wish granting genie most likely has their origin in the One Thousand and One nights compilation of folk tales but since that is a Persian work of literature the genie is actually the div (or daeva) of Persian mythology and not the djinn of Arabic origin. The two just got conflated in popular culture.
Even though modern genies are an amalgamation of different mythological creatures they have kept some of the original properties of the creatures they came from. Genies can be good or evil or just neutral and they have different names according to their moral compass. Ifrits and marids are usually depicted as evil genies while their more benevolent compatriots are simply called Djinn. A very common trope is for the evil genies to interpret wishes literally or corrupt them somehow which brings misery and ruin to the wish maker while neutral or good genies will interpret the wishes in a more “common sense” way or even work to bring the wish maker happiness.
I never thought about the crossing of cultures with Persia, totally forgot about their daeva. I’m pretty sure this is what modern Western understanding of djnni comes from, as their mischievous nature is more pronounced.
But yes, I’m more familiar with djnni that just have their own agendas, and whether you’re caught up or not is on you, you know? Hahaha
Thanks for taking the time to explain! I love all forms of myth and folktales and such, so this is kind of like crack for me lol
sorry what was that last one?
Let me make the Jinn mythology clear.
- They are just like humans, with their own thoughts and morals.
- They can shapeshift.
Yes, they have twinks.
Look I’m allowed to dream okay
“whatever”
No the one before that.
A level 19 character with the best equipment available.
They generally interpret wishes very literally, so I think my caveats are applicable.
The additional cruelty might be more monkey’s paw, but I wouldn’t expect a typical genie to interpret these wishes exactly as intended.
The ghost in the lamp of the original Aladdin tale isn’t evil at all. And it doesn’t state any limits to its powers at all. Aladdin and his mother just wish for a good meal and not only does the genie grant it, he even puts the meal in glamorous silver tableware which Aladdin is able to sell piece by piece.
When the silver and the money are gone they wish for another meal and repeat that for months or maybe even years and Aladdin starts to learn the ins and outs of the silver trade.
And the whole story takes place in China.
Fair enough! Reminds me of an episode of the newer Cryptkeeper series involving a djinn. I recommend it if you ever get a chance!
Wow you’re really bad at thism
Here’s my twist on these.
-
America is now the poorest country in the world. You’re directly over drafting 10 people every day and it’s genuinely life ruining for them.
-
You can pronounce every language perfectly, I’ll even give the memorization buff. Unfortunately every 7 days every language changes to a new, completely unknown language. The world knows them, and doesn’t realize anything changed, but not you.
-
All of your gifts are perfect, and everyone knows. People know you can obtain the perfect thing, genuinely life changing gifts for people. And they’ll want it. You’ll never be able to escape it. Out to eat? “Aren’t you the gift person?” Order delivery “Hey btw can you give me a gift with this order?” good luck leaving your house.
-
That’s not a djinn, that’s Mephistopheles
-
Isn’t this just prompt engineering for LLMs?
LLM, genie, what’s the difference? Either one can do weird shit if you’re not specific enough
I’m just here for the fucking plan.

I love the behind the scenes explanation of “and they have a plan”.
No, they didn’t. Unless you count “kill all humans” as “a plan”.
The producers put that in the titles but blindsided the writers with it.
I’m still trying to figure out the plan 🙍
There is no plan. Even if you stole 1000 dollars every day from each of the world’s billionaires it would still not put a dent into their wealth even after doing it for a life time. You would need 1 000 000 days of stealing 1000 dollars per day to steal 1 billion. 1 million days is just over 2700 years.
Even if you stole 1000 dollars every day from each of the world’s billionaires it would still not put a dent into their wealth even after doing it for a life time.
You’re assuming the “plan” is to bankrupt billionaires, I think they were the target simply because they wouldn’t notice the money missing and the OOP would have an easier time going on about their business.
“great, I wish for that!”
Jack DeSena (voice of Sokka from Avatar) and Chris Smith did a hilarious video on the premise of trying to outsmart a genie with caveats and addendums: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lM0teS7PFMo
deleted by creator














